Evie Noakes reads The Hobbit through an anti-capitalist lens
J.R.R. Tolkien kickstarted a global phenomenon in 1937, when he published his first novel The Hobbit. It was an immediate success and the introduction to the beautiful, complex, high fantasy world of Middle Earth. Between 1937 and 1949, he wrote one of the most well-known and beloved trilogies of all time, The Lord of the Rings, as its sequel. This series was published in three volumes between 1954 and 1955, and was unsuccessful at the time, but it would soon gain incredible amounts of popularity. In the early 2000s, The Lord of the Rings film trilogy was released. These films were extremely successful, with The Return of the King being the first ever fantasy film to win Best Picture at The Oscars. Roughly 10 years after, director Peter Jackson returned to Tolkien’s world to make The Hobbit film trilogy. With another star-studded cast, these films were also highly successful and widely loved by fans. All of this is to say, there is a reason why Tolkien’s works have stood the test of time. The fundamental themes of the story were relevant at the time and are still relevant today.
So, why was The Hobbit particularly relevant at the time of release? During World War One, the arms industry was booming, which opened up employment opportunities. Businesses expanded rapidly to take advantage of the high demand for weapons, however by the late 1920s, there was an oversupply. Many working-class people were turned out of their jobs and by 1933, unemployment reached a peak of 3,000,000. This crisis led people to begin to criticize the system of capitalism. After all, it had failed countless families as well as the state of Britain itself. In late 1930, Tolkien drafted the first chapter of The Hobbit and began more sustained writing from 1931 onwards.
To me, it is evident that the novel was written during a time when the working-class were becoming conscious of their plight. The story follows a company of dwarves who want to reclaim their home, Erebor, and its mountain of treasure, both of which have been guarded by the devious dragon Smaug. They hire a hobbit, Bilbo Baggins, to be their burglar. He comes from the rolling hills of The Shire, where the citizens reap what they sow. Thorin’s folk are also a community that believe in working for what they need and want, and this determination is why they are so resolute in reclaiming their rightful property. Smaug stole thousands of years of accumulated wealth despite the fact it holds no sentimental value to him; he owns it simply to possess it fiercely. Tolkien emphasises that greed is the villain’s defining character trait and it is interesting to write such a character during a time when working class people were being forced out of their homes in the name of business. The writer also makes it clear that such greed changes a person’s character, as shown by Thorin’s dragon sickness. In his pursuit to reclaim what is his, he turns on the people around him including the other dwarves who have a right to the treasure. His violent protection of the wealth turns out to be his fatal flaw, but not before he has a change of heart. Critics and scholars often use the fact that dwarves and elves are also known to hoard their wealth as a counterargument for The Hobbit being representative of capitalism.
However, I would argue that dwarves and elves value what is theirs, and it may cause problems from time to time, but they are both still virtuous people. The elves are skilful and serene, and the dwarves are notoriously loyal and hardworking. Thorin’s last words are representative of what I believe Tolkien’s message was: “If more of us valued food and cheer and song above gold, it would be a merrier place.” Wealth does not equate to happiness and goodness. The capitalist economy that most countries are run under affect people’s lives in many severe ways. This is the reality we live in, not some dystopian fantasy. Late- stage capitalism affects daily food and gas prices; it escalates wars and leads us to forget what really matters. Tolkien’s universe focuses on the importance of friendship, community and fighting against prejudice. I believe that we should take a page out of his book and cling to these values as our flag instead.










